Tryout Season: The Questions Everybody Should Ask (and Nobody Does)

Tryout season doesn’t hit all at once. It rolls through in waves.

The 9U through 12U guys already had theirs. Those rosters are mostly set. The 13U and 14U teams just wrapped their spring and summer seasons, so their tryouts are starting this month while the field is still fresh in everyone’s mind. The 15U through 17U guys still have a couple weeks of real games left, so their tryouts won’t hit until the end of July, once the dust settles on this season.

Different ages, different timelines, same decision underneath it all: who’s on the team and why.

Every family in this window is about to hand a travel organization a few thousand dollars and trust them with a kid’s summer. Every coach is about to build a roster that will either function or fall apart depending on choices made in a two-hour tryout window. That’s a lot riding on a small amount of information.

A couple summers ago, when I took over a new group, I ran into a few guys who didn’t gel with me personality-wise, not because of talent, but because of habits. They didn’t understand why they couldn’t throw a bat or a helmet when things went bad. They didn’t understand why cursing on the field wasn’t going to fly in my dugout. Talented kids. Real ability. But I wasn’t going to spend an entire summer managing tantrums.

So now, before I take a kid, I ask around. What kind of teammate is he? How does he respond when he’s 0-for-3? Does his energy help a dugout or drain it? That question tells me more than his exit velocity ever will.

The Business Side Nobody Explains

Here’s something coaches owe families more honesty about: travel organizations need big rosters. That’s not a conspiracy, it’s math. Tournaments require enough bodies to field a team through a long weekend without gassing your pitching staff. Programs need depth in case of injury, in case of a no-show, in case a kid gets pulled up to a higher team. A 12-man roster looks great in April and falls apart the first time three guys get hurt in June.

But “we need bodies” and “we need your son specifically” are two different conversations, and families deserve to know which one they’re actually in. A big roster isn’t a bad thing. A roster where nobody ever talks to your kid about his actual role in it, that’s the problem.

Everybody, Somebody, Anybody, and Nobody

There’s an old quip I love, and it applies to developing the whole student-athlete better than almost anything I know:

There was an important job to be done, and Everybody was sure that Somebody would do it. Anybody could have done it, but Nobody did it. Somebody got angry about that, because it was Everybody’s job. Everybody thought Anybody could do it, but Nobody realized that Everybody wouldn’t do it. It ended up that Everybody blamed Somebody when Nobody did what Anybody could have done.

Read that again slowly. That’s the exact loop high school and travel coaches have been running for years: who’s responsible for developing this kid, mentally, mechanically, as a human being? High school coaches sometimes think travel ball is just showcases and player egos. Travel coaches sometimes think high school ball is politics and limited reps. Both sides have a point. Neither side gets to opt out.

I’m blessed to coach on both sides of that fence. And I’ll tell you plainly: it’s everybody’s job. High school coaches, travel coaches, and parents are all in the same boat, trying to get the same kid to the same finish line. The organizations that win long-term are the ones where those coaches actually talk to each other instead of quietly blaming each other.

For Coaches

Don’t chase talent just because it’s talent. If there’s a stud free agent hitting the tryout circuit right now, do your homework before you offer him a jersey. There’s usually a reason a talented kid is available in July. Sometimes it’s an innocent reason. Sometimes it’s not.

Ask the harder question: will this kid add value to your team, or are you buying a bat at the cost of your standard? A kid who can’t throw a helmet without an incident, who runs his mouth at umpires, who treats teammates like scenery, costs you more in June than his tools are worth in April. I’m not dealing with that all summer, and neither should you.

Build the relationship with your players’ high school coaches. You need each other. Neither one of you develops these kids alone, and both of you are asking a family to invest real money and trust in the outcome. Be worthy stewards of both.

For Players

Get honest about what you actually want before you walk into a tryout. Is it a big name on the jersey, or is it real playing time and real development? Those aren’t always the same organization, and chasing a brand over a role is one of the most common regrets I hear from kids a year later.

Talk to teammates who have played for other organizations. Ask them what it was actually like, not what the Instagram highlights looked like. Talk to your high school coach too, even the ones who aren’t big fans of travel ball. He’s watched more of your development than almost anyone, and his opinion is worth more than a stranger’s sales pitch.

And when you sit down with a new coach, ask him directly: what role do you see for me on this team? Am I a depth piece, or am I an everyday starter? You deserve a real answer before you commit, not a vague one after you’ve already paid.

For Parents

Adults are going to sell you an image. That’s the nature of a business built on hope and highlight reels. Your job is to see past it.

Ask the coach directly: what are you going to do to develop my son, not just as a baseball player, but as a person? A coach who lets a dugout run wild, bats flying, helmets slamming, language nobody would tolerate at home, is not developing anybody. He’s just hoping the scoreboard covers for him.

You’re being asked to invest thousands of dollars in a summer. You have every right to ask hard questions before you write the check, and you shouldn’t feel guilty for asking them. A good coach will welcome the question. A coach who gets defensive about it just told you everything you need to know.

This Week

If your age group is heading into tryouts in the next few weeks, here’s your homework depending on which seat you’re in.

Coaches: Before you offer a roster spot, ask two people who’ve coached or played with that kid one simple question: what kind of teammate is he? Weigh the answer as heavily as you weigh his tools.

Players: Write down what you actually want this season, playing time, development, or a name on your chest, and be honest with yourself about which one it really is. Then ask your prospective coach what role he sees for you, and listen closely to how he answers.

Parents: Ask the coach what his plan is for developing your son as a person, not just a player. Watch how he runs his dugout before you ever sign a check. The way he handles a bad inning tells you more than any sales pitch ever will.

Nobody develops these kids alone. Everybody has a piece of the job. Let’s make sure somebody actually does it.

Let’s get to work. — Coach O


Discover more from Coach Shawn Oliver Leadership

Subscribe to get the latest posts sent to your email.

Leave a Reply

Who’s the Coach?

I’m Coach O, Shawn Oliver. I’m a head coach and teacher with a doctorate in educational leadership, and the author of Red Letters and Red Dirt. I help coaches and leaders stop paying the red dirt tax and start leading from secured worth – on the field, at home, and everywhere it counts.

The Weekly Game Plan

Don’t step out onto the dirt unprepared. Every week, get a short, raw breakdown of leadership alignment, culture-building, and Red Letter truth to help you protect your roster and lead with absolute clarity.

Don’t step out onto the dirt unprepared. Every week, get a short, raw breakdown of leadership alignment, culture-building, and Red Letter truth to help you protect your roster and lead with absolute clarity.

Worn Holy Bible and Rawlings official baseball on rustic wooden table