Love Your Athletes: What I Told a Young Coach at Lunch Yesterday

My AD asked me in the spring if I’d be willing to mentor a young coach on our staff. I said yes before he finished asking the question.

I said yes fast because I remember exactly what it felt like to be handed a program for the first time with no idea what I was actually doing. It wasn’t that long ago. A few short years, if I’m honest, though it feels like a different lifetime. I’ve got aspirations of my own, an athletic director’s chair someday, maybe a head of school’s office after that, and I’ve come to believe the only way you get ready for those seats is by starting to use those muscles now. That’s a lot of why I write these posts. It’s why I want to stand in front of coaches, teachers, and other leaders at conferences someday. Every one of these is a rep.

So yesterday I sat down for lunch with this young coach, and it was fantastic. I’m grateful to work somewhere that values that kind of investment, an AD who thinks to ask, a school that gives us the room to actually build relationships instead of just filling a staffing chart.

We talked shop for a while first. He’s a basketball guy who also coaches AAU, and he wanted to know how I balance high school ball with travel baseball. He asked me straight up what I think about people accusing coaches like us of “recruiting.” I told him the truth: it’s a heck of a way to make extra money doing something you already love, and as long as you’re operating with integrity and staying inside the rules, there’s nothing wrong with any of it. You’ll always have somebody making accusations, usually because they’re jealous of something you’ve built and they need a reason it isn’t fair. I told him I want my face out in the community. I want people to wonder why our program looks different, then go home, Google me, and find out I work somewhere spectacular with great teachers and one of the best facilities in the state of Georgia. That’s not vanity. That’s advertising the truth. If we don’t brag on the rockstars I get to lead and the place I get to lead them from, we’re doing them a disservice.

Good conversation. But then he asked me the question that actually mattered.

“If you had one piece of advice for a young coach, what would it be?”

Love Your Athletes First

The first thing out of my mouth, before I’d even thought about it, was three words: love your athletes.

Put them first. Every decision, every season, every hard call. Your ego doesn’t get a vote. If you build the habit of running your decisions through that filter, you’ll land on the right side of things far more often than the wrong one. That doesn’t mean everybody agrees with you every time. It means you’ll be able to live with yourself either way, because you weren’t protecting yourself when you made the call. If you’re making decisions out of your own selfish ambition, you will get crushed by the stress, because now every outcome is a referendum on you rather than a decision made on their behalf.

I told him the practical version of loving your athletes first: give them the credit when things go right, and take the blame yourself when they don’t. You’re the adult. You’ve got broad shoulders. You can wear a loss better than a seventeen-year-old can. When you’re young and dumb (and I was both), it’s so easy to transfer the blame somewhere else, to the ump, to a parent, to a kid who missed his spot. But every time you do that in front of your team, you’re teaching them it’s okay to do the same thing to each other. Your ego doesn’t matter. We get the incredible privilege of being called “coach” by young people who are watching everything we do, and at the end of the day, we need them a whole lot more than they need us.

Paul wrote something to the church at Philippi that I think about constantly, on a baseball field and everywhere else:

“Do nothing from selfish ambition or conceit, but in humility count others more significant than yourselves. Let each of you look not only to his own interests, but also to the interests of others.” (Philippians 2:3-4, ESV)

That’s not soft. That’s the whole job description.

Fill the Silence Before They Do

My second piece of advice: over-communicate. It sounds simple until you actually try to live it out.

I told him about our weekly emails, our daily practice schedules posted where players can see them, and the live Google Doc that our parents can access anytime. If something changes, they know it before it becomes a rumor, because it’s already sitting there in black and white. Here’s the principle underneath all of it: parents will fill the quiet with their own narrative. If you leave a gap, somebody fills it, and it’s almost never with the most generous explanation. The same is true for your players. If you don’t explain why, they’ll invent their own why, and their version is usually worse than the truth.

He told me a story right back that proved the point better than I could have. His former head coach once told the girls on his team, flatly, that they needed to be better conditioned. That was it. No context, no why. Left it right there.

The families filled that blank space themselves. Did coach just body-shame us?

Compare that to something like: “We’re running out of gas late in games and losing leads we should hold. I believe our conditioning is part of that, so we’re going to work on it hard over the next couple of weeks so we can finish what we start.” Same message. Same expectation. Completely different outcome, because nobody was left to guess at your intent.

Don’t Be a Slave to the Clock

The last piece tied back to something he’d asked about earlier: practice planning. Have a plan, always. But don’t be a slave to it. If a period isn’t working, kill it and move on rather than grinding out the minutes because the schedule says you have to. If something’s really grooving and your guys are getting great work out of it, stay in it longer and figure out where to push whatever you missed to tomorrow. The plan serves the players. The players don’t serve the plan.

The Scoreboard I’m Actually Chasing

I told him loving your athletes first doesn’t mean you stop wanting things for yourself. I’ve got real goals. I’d love to coach long enough and with enough good players to end up in the Georgia High School Baseball Hall of Fame someday. I’d love thirty years at Fellowship, and a number or a name hanging on that fence when I finally step back, not for the ego of it, but because of what it would mean about the impact made along the way.

But if none of that ever happens, I’m not worried about it. My real scoreboard is wedding invitations. Birth announcements. A text out of nowhere from a guy I coached a decade ago telling me how he’s doing in the world now that he’s a man instead of a kid in my dugout. That’s the only stat line I actually track.

I’ve butchered a few of those relationships along the way. I was young once too, and young coaches make selfish calls they don’t even recognize as selfish until years later. But I’m still on the sideline cheering for every one of those guys, even the ones who don’t wear the jersey anymore, because putting the jersey down doesn’t put down the relationship. I’m their biggest fan forever. That part of the job never ends, no matter what title I end up holding down the road.

The Application

This week, find your own answer to the question that young coach asked me. Not my answer, borrowed and repeated. Yours. If a rookie coach sat across from you at lunch and asked what one thing you’d tell them, what would actually come out of your mouth first, before you had time to think of something impressive?

Write it down. Then take somebody out for that lunch. You don’t have to wait for an AD to assign it to you. Find the newest, most overwhelmed coach in your building or your league and buy him a sandwich. Ask him what he’s struggling with instead of telling him what you know. Somebody did that for you once, even if it doesn’t feel like it some days. Pass it on.

I’m grateful for every hard season that got me here, the ones I handled well and the ones I botched completely, because the storms are usually what show you who you actually are. I pray I keep honoring God with what I’ve learned from them, and that I lead my men well for as long as I get the privilege of being called coach.

Greater Together, Coach O


Discover more from Coach Shawn Oliver Leadership

Subscribe to get the latest posts sent to your email.

Leave a Reply

Who’s the Coach?

I’m Coach O, Shawn Oliver. I’m a head coach and teacher with a doctorate in educational leadership, and the author of Red Letters and Red Dirt. I help coaches and leaders stop paying the red dirt tax and start leading from secured worth – on the field, at home, and everywhere it counts.

The Weekly Game Plan

Don’t step out onto the dirt unprepared. Every week, get a short, raw breakdown of leadership alignment, culture-building, and Red Letter truth to help you protect your roster and lead with absolute clarity.

Don’t step out onto the dirt unprepared. Every week, get a short, raw breakdown of leadership alignment, culture-building, and Red Letter truth to help you protect your roster and lead with absolute clarity.

Worn Holy Bible and Rawlings official baseball on rustic wooden table