Running on Empty Looks Like Attitude

He’d been one of your steadiest kids all fall. Shows up early, says “yes sir,” runs out every ground ball like it’s the region final.

Then, for about a week, he’s not that kid anymore.

Short with a teammate over nothing. Late to a drill he’s never been late to. Mouths off, quiet under his breath, when you correct his footwork on a routine relay. Nothing huge. Just enough that you notice, and enough that it’s starting to spread. A couple other guys pick up on his tone and match it.

Your gut says what every coach’s gut says: this is an attitude problem, and attitude problems get handled. You run the consequence. Extra work, a conversation about respect, maybe a seat on the bench for a scrimmage to make the point stick.

Here’s the question I want you to ask before you do any of that: when did you last ask him how his week actually went?

The Week I Almost Got It Backward

I’ve coached that exact kid more than once, and for years I handled him the same wrong way. Attitude is attitude. You don’t ask a fourteen-year-old to explain himself; you correct the behavior and move on. That’s what I was taught, and for a long time it worked well enough that I never questioned it.

What I’ve learned the hard way is that “well enough” isn’t the same as right. A couple of times I ran a kid through the standard attitude consequence, the extra conditioning, the sit-down about respect, and found out later, sometimes weeks later, that the actual story was a parent who’d just lost a job, or three tests in one week on top of a travel tournament, or a kid quietly trying to hold down a part-time shift so he could pay for his own gear. None of that showed up on my scouting report. It just showed up as a short fuse and a bad rep in the cage.

I wasn’t wrong that something needed to change. I was wrong about what I was trying to fix.

Attitude Is Rarely the First Problem

Here’s the turn, and I want you to sit with it, because it runs counter to almost everything coaching culture teaches you about toughness.

Attitude is rarely the first problem. It’s usually the last symptom of something that ran out earlier in the week.

Players run empty too. We talk a lot in this framework about coaches running empty, about the tank that gets spent on other people’s kids until there’s nothing left for your own family. That’s real, and it’s the Coach panel of what we’ve been building this month. But the chain runs the other direction first. Before a coach can run empty pouring into a player, that player is already carrying a full week of school, home, a travel schedule that doesn’t care about his bedtime, and whatever’s happening in his house that he’s not going to volunteer to you unprompted. He’s fifteen or sixteen. He doesn’t have the language yet to say, “Coach, I’m running on fumes.” What he’s got is a shorter fuse and less patience for a correction he’d have taken fine on a normal Tuesday.

That’s not an excuse. It’s a diagnosis. And you cannot treat a diagnosis like a discipline problem without making it worse.

What Running Empty Actually Looks Like

It rarely looks like exhaustion. If it looked like exhaustion, you’d have caught it already. It looks like:

Irritability that’s out of proportion to whatever just happened. A missed rep that used to get a shrug now gets a slammed helmet.

Uncharacteristic mistakes from a kid who’s usually locked in. Routine plays start looking careless, not because his skill dropped, but because his attention has nowhere left to draw from.

Going quiet in a way that’s different from his normal quiet. Pulling to the edge of the group at practice instead of being in the middle of it.

Snapping at a teammate over something that, a month ago, wouldn’t have registered.

Every one of those can also just be a kid having a bad attitude. That’s what makes this hard. The behaviors look identical from the dugout. The only way to tell the difference is to actually ask, and most of us skip that step because asking takes longer than running the consequence, and running the consequence feels like leadership.

What It Costs When You Get This Backward

If you treat an empty tank like defiance, you punish a kid for something he didn’t choose, and he knows it even if he can’t articulate why the consequence felt unfair. You don’t just lose that conversation. You lose a piece of his trust in the standard itself, and trust like that is expensive to rebuild.

And your roster is watching. This is where the 10-80-10 rule matters. Most of your kids, the reliable middle 80 percent, aren’t going to test you directly. But they are always clocking how you handle the kid who’s struggling, because that tells them exactly how much grace exists in your program and how much of it is actually earned versus performed. Handle a running-empty kid like a discipline case, and you’ve just taught your best kids that struggle gets punished here, not diagnosed. That’s a lesson they’ll remember longer than any lineup card.

Handle it right, and you build the opposite. Broad shoulders, small ego, means you can absorb the short fuse without matching it, ask the question underneath the behavior, and still hold the standard once you know what you’re actually dealing with. Those two things aren’t in tension. You can ask what’s going on and still expect him to run out the ground ball. Compassion isn’t the absence of a standard. It’s what makes the standard land as care, not control.

And we urge you, brothers, admonish the idle, encourage the fainthearted, help the weak, be patient with them all. 1 Thessalonians 5:14, ESV

Read that verse slowly. It doesn’t say treat everyone the same. It says three different people need three different things: the idle need admonishing, the fainthearted need encouragement, the weak need help. A coach who only knows one response, correction, is going to misapply it to at least two of those three groups every single week. Knowing which one you’re looking at requires asking before you respond.

What To Do This Week

The next time a normally steady kid has an off week, attitude, uncharacteristic mistakes, short with teammates, don’t lead with the consequence. Lead with one question, asked privately, not in front of the group: “This isn’t like you. What’s going on this week?”

That’s it. Not a lecture. Not an accusation. One honest question, asked like you actually want the answer.

Sometimes the answer is nothing, and he just needs to be told to reset his attitude, and now you can do that with a clear conscience because you checked first. Sometimes the answer is a full week of tests and a tournament and a house that’s tense right now, and you just saved yourself from disciplining a kid for running out of a resource he never chose to spend.

Either way, you’ll know. And so will he, that you looked past the behavior long enough to ask what was underneath it. That’s the kind of thing a kid remembers for years, long after he’s forgotten the score of whatever game this happened during.

Greater Together


Discover more from Coach Shawn Oliver Leadership

Subscribe to get the latest posts sent to your email.

Leave a Reply

Who’s the Coach?

I’m Coach O, Shawn Oliver. I’m a head coach and teacher with a doctorate in educational leadership, and the author of Red Letters and Red Dirt. I help coaches and leaders stop paying the red dirt tax and start leading from secured worth – on the field, at home, and everywhere it counts.

The Weekly Game Plan

Don’t step out onto the dirt unprepared. Every week, get a short, raw breakdown of leadership alignment, culture-building, and Red Letter truth to help you protect your roster and lead with absolute clarity.

Don’t step out onto the dirt unprepared. Every week, get a short, raw breakdown of leadership alignment, culture-building, and Red Letter truth to help you protect your roster and lead with absolute clarity.

Worn Holy Bible and Rawlings official baseball on rustic wooden table