He went 0-for-4, and he walked off the field like somebody had read him a death sentence.
You know the walk. Helmet in his hand, eyes on his cleats, and nobody in the dugout quite sure where to look. The next day you ask him how he’s feeling and he says, “I’m just not a good hitter.”
Not “I had a bad day.” Not “I’m in a slump.” I’m not a good hitter.
That’s not a swing problem. That’s a name change. Somewhere along the way, a kid stopped being a person who hits and became a number that hits, and the number is not kind.
The Number Is Honest. It’s Just Not Everything.
Let me say something before I go any further. I’m not against stats. A scorebook doesn’t lie. It tells you what happened, and a coach who ignores it is guessing.
But look at what baseball actually asks a hitter to do. Fail seven times out of ten, and we put you in the Hall of Fame. The best hitters alive are wrong most of the time, and the game still calls them the best. No other sport hands out that much failure and still expects a kid to stand back in the box with a straight face.
So a number measures what happened. It cannot measure who he is. The trouble starts when everybody around the kid forgets the difference, and that includes us.
The Parking Lot
In 2021, I took over a travel team from a coach who had left the organization. The families didn’t know me yet. They were comfortable with the old way.
One player’s parents had been told their son was the apex of the roster: ace on the mound, primary catcher, best hitter. Then the live reps told a different story. On the mound, 2 innings, 5 walks, 4 earned runs. At the plate, 1-for-12. Behind the plate, passed balls piling up.
So I adjusted the lineup based on what I saw. His at-bats dropped. No innings pitched. A role in the consolation game only.
After a game, those parents cornered me in the parking lot. I held my ground on the baseball. They disagreed, and they left the program. The team went on to a great summer and won a tournament.
I’ve thought about that conversation a lot since then. I can’t see inside that family, and I won’t pretend to. But I don’t think they were fighting for innings. I think they were fighting for an identity. Somebody had told them their son was the best, and when the numbers said otherwise, it felt like I was attacking him. The kid and the stat line had already merged.
And that’s the thing. When a player’s name gets welded to his numbers, a bad week isn’t a bad week anymore. It’s an indictment.
The Kid Who Didn’t Merge
Now let me brag on a guy, because I get to.
He was a rockstar at shortstop. We knew he’d be good. He knew he was good. Here’s the best part: he never acted as if he knew it. He was one of our hardest workers; he refused to settle for good enough, and his teammates gravitated to that. He was a natural leader. He still shows up on campus and hits with our guys during Summer/Thanksgiving/Christmas.
In the second game of his senior year of high school, he jammed his thumb on an opponent’s helmet, making a tag on a steal attempt. He had a little reaction and finished the game. The next morning he woke up in a ton of pain. The doctor found a hairline fracture. Three weeks on the shelf.
When he came back, his timing was off, and it showed. This is a kid who struck out 22 times in his first three years of high school ball combined. He was a stud, and everybody knew it. Now he was struggling to see pitches, and the thumb still wasn’t all the way back. He went about 4-for-15 over his next five games, including three straight games with two strikeouts each.
After that third game, he found me and vented a little. He needed to get the negativity out so he could be himself again.
His answer to three straight two-strikeout games? The first three-homer game in school history. It’s on YouTube, it’s a fun watch.
Look at what he did. He didn’t bottle it up and let the number tell him who he was. He said it out loud, to somebody he trusted, and then he let it go. He separated what was happening to him from who he was.
That didn’t start that week. He built it. And it has traveled with him.
He went on to be a three-year starter at an Ivy League school, and he keeps pushing himself to be great. Then it happened again. In his junior year of college he started 0-for-something with somewhere around fifteen strikeouts. I wasn’t worried. I knew who he was. Of course he bounced back, and he earned first-team All-Ivy.
I’m proud of that joker.
I Did It With a Different Column
Here’s the part that’s harder to write.
I did the exact same thing, just with a different column. When I was a young head coach, I was fueled by ego and by wanting to prove people wrong. I was looking at the wrong scoreboard. I measured myself by my record more than I’d ever admit. If a kid becomes his batting average, a coach becomes his win-loss record. Same disease. Different jersey.
Think about the 2020 season. We started 9-0, and then COVID shut it down. That record will never have a finish. Nine and zero, forever, with no tenth game.
I can tell you what that taught me about records. A record is a fact about a team on a given stretch of days. It is not a verdict on a person. If my worth had been sitting in that 9-0, I’d have been holding an unfinished sentence for the rest of my life.
Nobody should hand a teenager something heavier than a grown man can carry.
Why Coaches Hand Kids the Only Mirror We Own
Jeff Duke’s 3D Coach describes coaching in three dimensions: the skills and strategies of the game, the mind, and the heart. I’ve been working through it this month.
Here’s my read on why this problem is so common. The batting average lives in the first dimension. It’s visible. It’s printed. It’s easy to talk about. So when a kid is struggling, the only thing most of us can see, name, and fix is the first dimension. We talk about his hands, his hips, his timing, his numbers.
And without meaning to, we become the mirror. Every conversation tells him the thing worth talking about is the thing that’s in the scorebook.
He is not a first-dimension creature. Neither are you. What he believes about himself lives in the third dimension, in the heart, and if we never go there, the scorebook will win by default. It will be the loudest voice in his life, and the scoreboard is the loudest liar in the building.
Jesus asked it plainly in Matthew 16:26: “What will it benefit someone if he gains the whole world yet loses his life?” A .400 average and a lost kid is a trade I don’t want to make.
Watch the Language
Ken Ravizza taught that the key skill isn’t staying green forever. It’s recognizing the yellow light. So what does the yellow light look like when a kid is becoming his average?
It’s rarely the slump. It’s the sentence.
“I’m a .210 hitter.” “I always choke in this spot.” “I’m not a closer.” “That’s just who I am.” Any time a player stops describing what happened and starts describing what he is, that’s the yellow. Monday’s post was about the pitcher who says, “I always struggle with this team.” Same sentence, different position.
Recognize it. Then, instead of fixing his swing, you challenge his noun.
Run It This Week
The first sentence rule. After a hard game, the first thing you say to a kid is not about the at-bat. Not the strikeout, not the error, not the walk. Ask about his day, his arm, his week, anything true. Make him feel, before he hears a single critique, that he walked into the dugout as the same person he walked out of it as.
Know three things the scorebook can’t hold. For every hitter on your roster, write down three things about him that have nothing to do with performance. Start with the five quietest kids. If you can’t write three, you’ve found your homework.
Be the person he can vent to. When a kid finds you after a bad game and needs to get it out, don’t fix him and don’t lecture him. Let him say it. My shortstop needed to vocalize the struggle so he could move past it, and he could only do that because somebody was willing to listen. Then let him go play.
Run your own audit. Say your record out loud. Then say, “That is what happened. It is not who I am.” If that sentence feels false in your mouth, you’ve been paying the Red Dirt Tax, and the tax always gets paid by someone.
And if you wrote a commitment card on 10/2, read it tonight and ask whether it would survive an 0-for-4 week. If one of your four lines only holds when the team is winning, it isn’t a commitment. It’s a forecast. Rewrite it so it holds on the worst Friday of the season. We’ll read them together on 10/30.
One Last Thing
A kid who knows his worth isn’t tied to his average can afford to be wrong. He can stand in against a hard thrower, take a risk on a pitch, and go 0-for-4 on Friday and be fine on Saturday. That’s what secured worth buys, and it’s what we’re really building when we build a hitter.
Monday we’ll talk about what happens when the coach is the one winning at work and losing at home.
For tonight, find the kid who’s been walking off the field a little slower than the rest.
The scoreboard will lie to you. Your worth isn’t on it. Neither is his.
Greater Together.

Leave a Reply