Winning on the Wrong Scoreboard

We missed the playoffs in 2017 by .173.

Not a game. Not a run. A decimal point in a power ranking, and I have thought about that decimal more than I’ve thought about most of my wins.

My first year at Fellowship, we finished 16-13. We had lost five in a row, and twice in that stretch I’d watched a late lead disappear against a region team. Then came a forced crossover series. We won it, 11-1, 5-0, and 9-2. Three wins, and the rankings still dropped and pushed us out.

So the next year, I scheduled for the rankings.

The Fix That Worked, and the Price

In 2018, my second year, I figured out how to schedule around the power rankings. And it worked. We beat a rival for the first time in school history. We earned the chance to host a playoff game on our own campus for the first time in school history.

It was our first successful season, and I was proud of it.

Then I went back and looked at the pitching stats.

I had two guys at 68 innings and 60 innings. My shortstop and my third baseman. My backup shortstop threw 35. Two others threw 26 and 23.

Five arms. Those five covered all but 15 innings of the entire year.

When the postseason came, my horses were worn out. I had burned bullets in March that I needed in May, and I’d done it for the ego of a better ranking. The rest of the staff sat. One of those five was a senior, so he was gone. And a couple of kids who never pitched that year were gone too, because of course they were. I never used them.

That’s the part that gets me. The scoreboard said we were winning. The kids who didn’t pitch were learning something else.

I Didn’t Learn My Lesson

Here’s the honest part. I did it again.

In 2019 my top four arms threw 63, 62, 44, and 32 innings. The rest of the staff combined for 21. We made the Elite 8 that year, so on paper it was a success. But I knew what it was. Same engine, same fuel.

I was chasing the wrong scoreboard. The ranking was a real number, and it felt like proof of a good job. But it measured something about me, not about the kids.

What Changed

Now, in recent seasons, my top arms spread out like this: 59, 51, 45, 24, 22, and 11. My top guys rarely make it to 60 innings unless we play deep into the final four.

I could still do a much better job, and I know it. But here’s what I believe now.

In a three-game series you need six or seven guys you trust to get outs. Nobody builds that staff in May. You build it in the spring, by giving them the ball earlier, when the stakes are lower, and by letting them struggle.

That means I sacrifice some wins on the scoreboard for kids’ development. It means that in high school, where runs allowed doesn’t change much, I can afford not to run-rule a game so a guy can get his work. It’s different in travel ball pool play, where saving a bullet can matter. But in the regular season, let them get out there and fail. You don’t know what you don’t know. Practice can never replicate the pressure of taking a varsity mound for the first time.

I have three freshmen who are going to get a taste of that this spring, for exactly that reason. My staff and I have to be disciplined about carving out room for them and for my rising juniors. If we don’t plan it, it won’t happen. The season is always going to ask for the safe arm.

It Was Never Just a Pitching Problem

The power ranking was one version of the wrong scoreboard. There was another one running at the same time.

That same first year, I took every loss personally, and everyone in my life paid for it. The long hours. The constant stress. The inability to turn off the game. I could be sitting at my own table and still be standing in the third base box, replaying the fifth inning. You read about one of those nights last week, and I won’t retell it.

I wrote in my book that I took every loss personally and that my athletes, my students, my coworkers, and worst of all, my wife, suffered for it.

It’s the same disease. When my worth sits on the scoreboard, I spend whatever it takes to keep the number up. I’ll spend a freshman’s development. I’ll spend a senior’s last season. I’ll spend my wife’s evenings.

And the scoreboard will let me. It will tell me I’m doing great. That’s why it’s the loudest liar in the building. Losing at home is quiet. Nobody posts it. Nobody prints it. There’s no power ranking for the house.

That is the Red Dirt Tax. It drains your energy, your presence, and your relationships, and the tax always gets paid by someone.

What Two Other Coaches Saw

On June 12, 2017, I watched Matt Deggs sit in front of a room of reporters after his team had been swept out of the Super Regionals. He didn’t talk about Omaha. He said, “It’s not mission Omaha. It’s mission build and save lives.”

Two years later I read his book, 15 to 28. By his own telling, he had been a transactional coach who cared only about wins and losses, and the book is the story of what that cost him, including nearly losing his family, and what it took to come back. One line stopped me: “We need them way more than they need us.”

Then there’s Tony Robichaux, who won 1,177 games and is remembered, by the people who played for him, for something else. He used to say, “What you do should never be who you are.” After his death, his son finished a book he had been working on. It’s called The Real Game, and it’s about life, not baseball.

Two men who won a lot. Both of them are known for what they built in people.

I’m Still Working on This

I’d love to tell you I fixed this in 2019 and never looked back. I didn’t.

This past Saturday I got way more upset over a Georgia football loss than I had any business being. I’m not the coach. I wasn’t on the field. I have no control over any of it.

And it still got to me.

There is no reason for me to change who I am because of something completely out of my control. It isn’t fair to the people around me, and it isn’t fair to me.

But that’s the point. If a game I can’t touch can move me like that, imagine what the games I’m responsible for can do. The wrong scoreboard doesn’t care whose team it’s keeping score for.

I’m not telling you I’ve arrived. I’m telling you I’m still catching the yellow light. Recognize it, release it, refocus. Some Saturdays I’m better at it than others.

The Threshold

Here is what the work has built so far at my front door, and I wouldn’t trade it for a state title.

Now, when I walk through the front door, if my wife wants to know how the game went, she has to ask. She cannot tell by my demeanor whether we won or lost.

That is exactly how it should be. For her sake, and for mine.

It didn’t happen in a day. It happened when I decided the red dirt of my job doesn’t get to cross that line. I still feel the loss. I just don’t hand it to her.

Jesus put the whole question in one sentence: “What does it benefit someone to gain the whole world and yet lose his life?” (Mark 8:36)

You can win every game on the schedule and lose the people the schedule was supposed to be for.

Run It This Week

Find your wasted bullets. Pull your own numbers. Who carried the load last season, and who didn’t get a chance? Write down the three kids who got the fewest opportunities, whether it’s innings, at-bats, or reps. Decide where they get real exposure this fall or winter, while it’s cheap.

Name your ranking. Everyone has one. For me it was the power ranking. Yours might be a seed, a playoff berth, a win total, or what the booster club thinks. Ask: what am I willing to spend to protect it, and who is paying?

Pick a threshold. Choose a place between the ballpark and your house: the parking lot, the last stoplight, the mailbox. Before you cross it, decide what you’re leaving there. After a loss I take a drink of water, breathe, and drain the chaos instead of pouring gasoline on it. Find your version.

Update your card. If you wrote a commitment card on 10/2, add a line: I will give the next kid a real chance before I need him. Date it. We’ll read them together on 10/30.

One Last Thing

The kids who never got the ball in 2018 didn’t show up in any standings. Neither did the evenings at home. That is the whole problem with the wrong scoreboard. It only counts what it can count.

Wednesday we’ll look at a conversation Jesus had on a beach with a man who had failed him in the worst way. It’s about restoration, and it’s about the question He asked three times.

For now, go find the kid who hasn’t pitched yet.

The scoreboard will lie to you. Your worth isn’t on it. And neither is theirs.

Greater Together.


Discover more from Coach Shawn Oliver Leadership

Subscribe to get the latest posts sent to your email.

Leave a Reply

Who’s the Coach?

I’m Coach O, Shawn Oliver. I’m a head coach and teacher with a doctorate in educational leadership, and the author of Red Letters and Red Dirt. I help coaches and leaders stop paying the red dirt tax and start leading from secured worth – on the field, at home, and everywhere it counts.

The Weekly Game Plan

Don’t step out onto the dirt unprepared. Every week, get a short, raw breakdown of leadership alignment, culture-building, and Red Letter truth to help you protect your roster and lead with absolute clarity.

Don’t step out onto the dirt unprepared. Every week, get a short, raw breakdown of leadership alignment, culture-building, and Red Letter truth to help you protect your roster and lead with absolute clarity.

Worn Holy Bible and Rawlings official baseball on rustic wooden table