I took a momentum-changing double play and wiped it out by holding up four fingers.
It cost our program its first region title in school history.
I’m thankful for it now. It took me a few seasons to be able to say that.
The Good Comes First
Before I get to the hard part, I want to say this out loud, and Thanksgiving week is a good time for it.
I’ve been given a lot of good seasons.
I watched Cody Tapley hit a walk-off home run over the scoreboard at Wesleyan in Game 2 of an Elite 8 series. I’ve been part of more wins than I deserve to have my name on. Jessica and I have watched young men I coached marry the women they love.
Those were real. I’m grateful for every one of them, and I’d take any of them again in a heartbeat.
The good seasons mattered. They just taught me less than the one that broke me.
Chickamauga
Chickamauga is a fine community up near the Tennessee line, about two hours from our school. In 2019, we earned the right to drive up there and play one of the best teams in the state for the first region championship in Fellowship baseball history.
Our region was big back then, so it was split into two sides of eight, kind of like the AL and NL. In the region tournament, the top four on each side crossed over. Our 1 played their 4, our 2 played their 3, and so on. That way you balanced it out.
We were the 1. So were they.
The opening game went about as well as it could. We cruised early, and I pulled our number three starter after three innings so I could roll him back out on Friday if I needed him. In game two, our number two went out and won it about as much as one guy can win a baseball game. Five innings of one-run ball, and he drove in all four of our runs in a 4-3 win.
The plan had worked perfectly. Our ace was on the mound for the title game. Back then, region champions jumped to the top of the power rankings for the playoffs, no matter where they ranked. That held for the last couple of years too, and then even the two-seed jumped. This year, teams stay where they’re ranked, and the only jump is a region champ outside the top 16. I’m grateful Georgia changed that. Back in 2019, we were set up.
We put up two in the first and four more in the fourth. Six to nothing going into the sixth.
I was frustrated for most of that game. Our ace was way ahead of hitters all night, and the plate umpire would not call strike three. A buddy of mine had coached up there that Wednesday and dealt with the same thing. That was sitting in my young, dumb coaching brain. I’d come a long way from the guy who made the newspaper, but I still fought my emotions when it felt like the zone or game was going one way.
And coaches, it always feels like the zone is going one way. Doesn’t it?
Here’s what I still have on my scorecard. Our ace averaged 10 strikeouts a game. That night he had 14 batters in 0-2 counts out of 25 he faced. He finished with five strikeouts, and none of them were looking. I still believe that with a consistent zone, he’s out of there with a Maddux.
He was frustrated. My catcher was frustrated. The leader of our dugout was frustrated. We were still up 6-0, and our ace was cruising.
One hitter had barreled him up both times through the lineup. The second time, he hit one over the left field wall. Fine. It’s 6-2.
But he was at 90 pitches, and 34 of them had come after an 0-2 count. Then a hit batter. Then a walk. At 97 pitches, it was time to go get him.
Our change-of-pace guy came in. A fly ball that was absolutely touched, and our fielder ran down with a great play. Then a hard ground ball, and another run crossed. 6-3. Then a ground ball to third, and our third baseman threw to second for the force. Five-four FC to end the inning.
In the seventh, I went back to Monday’s starter. Hit batter to start the inning, because nothing in high school baseball is easy. Then a 3-2 walk. Tying run at the plate, and the guy who’d mashed two baseballs sitting on deck.
Then a ground ball to third. Five, four, three. Double play.
Two outs. Runner on third. Up three. Their best hitter walking to the plate.
The coach I am today knows what that means. Even if he touches another one, it’s 6-5 and you’re still winning.
The 2019 version of me saw the guy on deck. He’d punched out on a fastball in back-to-back at-bats. I wanted to kill their momentum. I didn’t want their best player to beat us.
So I held up four fingers. Intentional walk.
What a dummy.
Next batter. I could see our guys getting the Gatorade bucket ready at the end of the dugout. Parents were up and cheering.
Strike one. My heart rate came down.
Strike two, fouled off on a fastball. Here we go. My plan worked. Look how smart I am. It was all about me.
When the ball left his hand, I knew it wasn’t a fastball. We’d called a changeup to speed his bat up. If we execute it, it works. We didn’t. We left it middle-middle, and he hit it into the trees.
Tie game. Seventh inning. Two outs. Because the head coach decided bringing the tying run to the plate was a game-changing decision.
It was. It changed the game in the wrong direction.
We lost in the bottom of the ninth. Bases loaded. Down the middle, ball. Down the middle, ball. Down the middle, ball. Down the middle, ball. Game over.
And I’ll be clear about this: that game isn’t on an umpire. It’s on me.
In the postgame meeting, I apologized to our players. I cost them a shot at history. Our 2020 seniors were juniors that night. I’m confident they would have won it the next year, but COVID took their senior spring before it had a chance to finish. Tomorrow isn’t promised.
I’m sure those two-hour rides home were full of families talking about how dumb that decision was. They were right. I deserved every word of it.
That game sat with me all night. It sat with me for a few seasons. It still sits with me every time I think about putting four fingers up.
In It, Not For It
I’m not grateful that we lost, and I won’t tell you to smile through a cut list or a playoff exit and call it a blessing by Monday. That’s pretending.
On Sunday I talked about 1 Thessalonians 5:18, where Paul says to give thanks in everything. Not for everything. In it. Paul and Silas weren’t thankful for the jail. They were thankful in it, because God was still God in there.
Pastor Joby Martin said something in a sermon that I haven’t been able to shake: “If you’re going to be great you’re going to endure pain.”
Paul said it first:
“And not only that, but we also boast in our afflictions, because we know that affliction produces endurance, endurance produces proven character, and proven character produces hope.” Romans 5:3-4 (CSB)
Paul boasts in what the affliction produces. I don’t thank God for the changeup that ended up in the trees. I thank Him for what He built out of it.
Here’s what Chickamauga built in me.
It showed me where my worth was anchored. That night, I wasn’t mad at anybody but myself, and it hurt so much because I’d made the night about me. “Look how smart I am” is a scoreboard thought. When the scoreboard turned, it took me with it. A hard loss is the only time you find out which voice you’ve been listening to.
It made me a better decision maker. I still believe in not letting their best player beat you. But I don’t put four fingers up without thinking about that night, and I think through the whole inning now, not just the next hitter.
And it gave me something to hand the next guy. When a young coach makes the call that costs his team a big game, I don’t have to fake it. I can tell him I’ve been there and he’s going to coach better because of it.
None of that shows up in a 30-win season. It only comes from the other kind.
Thankful to Wear the Egg
I’m grateful for that dumb decision. I’m grateful for every dumb decision I’ve made, and for the ones I’ll make in the future. Those are growth points.
Wearing the egg is humility with a price tag. Anybody can be humble when it’s free. It’s easy to say “nobody’s perfect” when nobody’s keeping score. It’s a different thing to stand in front of players and parents who watched you blow it and say, “That one’s on me.”
That’s why I’m thankful to wear the egg sometimes. Nothing cuts a head coach back down to size faster. Wins have a way of convincing you you’re smarter than you are. I held up four fingers because I thought I was the smartest guy in the park, and the egg was the bill.
Proverbs 11:2 says it plainly: “When arrogance comes, disgrace follows, but with humility comes wisdom.” I got the disgrace first. The wisdom took a few seasons.
Humility isn’t thinking less of yourself. It’s thinking of yourself less. It’s knowing your worth was never riding on the call you made in the seventh inning.
As coaches, we’ve got to be willing to wear the egg. Own it in front of your players. Grow from it. Then don’t be afraid to make the next mistake.
That last part matters most. A coach who’s scared of being wrong again coaches tight. He stops making calls. He covers himself instead of leading. Our players deserve a fearless leader who loves them and puts them first, and you can’t be fearless if you’re still carrying the last mistake around.
So I hold myself to the same thing I ask of my players. Evaluate where it went wrong. Decide what you’d do differently. Then flush it and get the next pitch.
If we want that to be the standard in our culture, we have to model it first.
This Weekend: Evaluate, Adjust, Flush
Friday’s post is the one you take into your weekend, so here’s your rep.
Find fifteen quiet minutes. Saturday morning with coffee works. Grab a notepad, not your phone. At the top, write down the call you’d take back. The game, the inning, the decision. Be specific.
Evaluate. Write down what went wrong and what it cost. Be honest. Don’t blame the umpire, the zone, or the player who didn’t execute. Write down your part.
Adjust. Write two lines. One thing you’d do differently. One thing that mistake built in you that you couldn’t have learned any other way.
Flush. Then close the notebook. You’ve worn the egg. You don’t have to carry it into next season.
One more thing before you flush it. Think about who stayed with you after that game. The assistant who didn’t pile on. The player who told you it was alright. The spouse who let you be quiet on the drive home.
That’s your thank-you note this week. We’re in Week 3 of the challenge, and the theme is the hard seasons. Write to the person who stayed. Tell them which game you mean.
Who’s getting your note this week?
Greater Together.

Leave a Reply